|  
 | After 
        his famous 1929 paper, 
        into the 1930s Edwin Hubble continued his campaign to prove the reality 
        of the velocity-distance relation he had announced. In the 1929 paper, 
        he remarked that "Mr. Humason at Mount Wilson has initiated a program 
        of determining velocities of the most distant nebulae that can be observed 
        with confidence.
 New data to be expected in the near future may 
        modify the significance of the present investigation, or, if confirmatory, 
        will lead to a solution having many times the weight." By 1931 
        Hubble and Humason had velocities for 40 more nebulae, 26 of them in 8 
        groups of galaxies. The greatest distance was now over a hundred million 
        light years. This was 50 times farther than the most distant spiral nebulae 
        in the 1929 report. The linear velocity-distance relation held. 
         
          |  Hubble's 
            1931 velocity-distance relation. Circles represent mean values for 
            clusters or groups of nebulae. Dots near the lower-left corner represent 
            individual nebulae. These and the lowest two circles were used in 
            the 1929 formulation of the velocity-distance relation.
 |  In 1934 
        Hubble and Humason reported results for isolated nebulae not in clusters. 
        Still the velocity-distance relation held. 
         
          |  Hubble's 
            1934 velocity-distance relation. The solid line represents the velocity-distance 
            relation determined from isolated nebulae. It parallels the velocity-distance 
            relation earlier determined from nebulae in clusters, represented 
            by the dashed line. The velocity-distance relation for isolated nebulae 
            is a magnitude brighter than the relation for nebulae in clusters. 
            This was attributed to selection effects  the brightest nebulae 
            were the easiest to find in isolation, whereas less bright nebulae 
            were found easily in clusters.
 |  By 1936 
        Hubble and Humason had data for a hundred more nebulae. The velocity-distance 
        relation was "still sensibly linear to a distance of 70 million parsecs 
        [more than 200 million light years]." 
         
          |  Hubble's 
            1936 velocity-distance relation. Numbers in parentheses following 
            the names of the clusters indicate the number of nebulae observed 
            in each cluster. Because the fainter nebulae in the most distant clusters 
            were below the observing limit of the 100-inch telescope, Humason 
            plotted, as an indication of distance, the magnitude of the fifth 
            brightest nebula in each of the clusters.
 |  |